FREE SHIPPING

On all orders over $60 excluding HI & AK

FREE SHIPPING On all orders over $60 excluding HI & AK

FREE SHIPPING

On all orders over $60 excluding HI & AK

FREE SHIPPING On all orders over $60 excluding HI & AK

Your cart

Your cart is empty

5 Common Cocktail Mistakes

And How to Fix Them

Crafting a great cocktail is an art, and small missteps can make the difference between a drink that impresses and one that falls flat. Whether you're a home bartender experimenting with mixology or looking to perfect classic recipes, avoiding these common mistakes will instantly improve your cocktails.

Let’s dive into five frequent cocktail mistakes and the simple fixes that will take your drinks to the next level.

1. Using the Wrong Ice (Or Forgetting About Ice Altogether)

Ice does more than just chill your drink—it controls dilution and affects texture. Using the wrong type, or worse, not using fresh ice, can lead to watery, bland cocktails or drinks that don't reach the right temperature.

The fix:

  • Use large, solid cubes for controlled dilution for shaken drinks like margaritas and daiquiris.
  • For stirred drinks like an old-fashioned, opt for a large, clear ice cube to keep it cold without over-diluting.
  • For highballs like a gin and tonic, fill the glass with ice to slow down melting and maintain carbonation.

If you want a more polished look, invest in clear ice molds or an ice sphere tray.

2. Over- or Under-Diluting Your Drink

Dilution is essential for a balanced cocktail, but over-shaking or under-stirring can result in a drink that’s either too strong or too weak.

The fix:

  • Shake cocktails for about 10-15 seconds until the shaker feels ice-cold. This properly chills, aerates, and dilutes the drink.
  • Stir cocktails like a negroni or manhattan for 20-30 seconds to achieve the right balance.

If your cocktail tastes harsh, stir or shake a little longer. If it’s too weak, reduce the shaking time.

3. Ignoring Fresh Ingredients

Using bottled citrus juice, old garnishes, or flat mixers can make even a great cocktail recipe taste mediocre.

The fix:

  • Always use freshly squeezed citrus juice—it makes a huge difference in flavor.
  • Keep herbs like mint or basil fresh by storing them in water, just like flowers.
  • Use high-quality mixers, such as real ginger beer or premium tonic, instead of generic store-brand sodas.

4. Overcomplicating the Drink

Too many ingredients or overly complex techniques can result in a muddled, unbalanced drink.

The Fix:

  • Stick to three to five key ingredients. This is the sweet spot for a well-balanced cocktail.
  • Master classic recipes before experimenting. Start with an old fashioned, margarita, or martini.
  • Let the base spirit shine rather than masking it with too many add-ins.

5. Neglecting the Glass and Garnish

The right glassware and garnish aren’t just about aesthetics—they impact flavor, aroma, and the overall drinking experience.

The Fix:

  • Use the correct glass for each drink. A coupe works for a daiquiri, while a rocks glass is best for an old fashioned.
  • Garnishes should be fresh and functional. A lemon twist releases essential oils, while a lime wheel adds acidity.
  • Chill your glassware before serving to keep drinks at the perfect temperature.

Expressing citrus peels over your cocktail before dropping them in adds a layer of aromatic complexity.

Small Fixes, Big Difference

Great cocktails don’t require fancy equipment or expert-level skills—just a few small adjustments can instantly improve your mixology game. Avoid these common mistakes, and you'll be serving up balanced, flavorful, and professional-looking cocktails in no time.

Learn More

Recipes, techniques, and products.